GS2 – International Relations
Context:
India and New Zealand held their first-ever Defence Strategic Dialogue in New Delhi, signalling a structured move towards stronger maritime and security cooperation.
Features of the Dialogue
- Shift in Diplomacy: Transition from ad hoc interactions to institutionalised defence engagement.
- Shared Objective: Build strategic partnerships to counter common Indo-Pacific security threats.
- Multilateral Cooperation: Strengthen coordination in regional forums to enhance collective security.
- Joint Training: Discussed military training and exercises to improve interoperability.
- Maritime Focus: Emphasised rules-based maritime order and freedom of navigation.
- White Shipping Data: Agreement to share maritime surveillance data for enhanced domain awareness.
Strategic Value of New Zealand for India
- Niche Capabilities: Offers access to the Pacific, intelligence sharing, and multilateral experience.
- Ideological Fit: NZ’s open Indo-Pacific policy complements India’s SAGAR and IPOI frameworks.
- Pacific Access: Acts as a gateway to the South Pacific and strengthens India’s regional outreach.
- Intelligence Advantage: NZ’s membership in the Five Eyes alliance enhances shared threat intelligence.
- Diplomatic Support: NZ backs India’s bid for a permanent seat in the UN Security Council.
- Normative Convergence: Both advocate for nuclear disarmament, non-proliferation, and counter-terrorism.
Challenges in Defence Cooperation
- Asymmetric Capacities: Significant disparities in defence strength affect deep collaboration.
- China Factor: NZ’s economic dependence on China limits strategic manoeuvrability with India.
- Defence Limitations: NZ’s small military restricts the scale of joint initiatives.
- Diaspora Extremism: India has raised concerns over Khalistan-linked activities in NZ’s Indian diaspora.
- Low Continuity: Engagements are episodic, lacking strong institutional momentum.
- Geopolitical Constraints: NZ’s Five Eyes role and neutral stance in the Pacific limit alignment with India’s Indo-Pacific strategies.