Chinmaya IAS Academy – Current Affairs Chinmaya IAS Academy – Current Affairs
Related Articles
States in the U.S. have the practice of emblazoning their vehicle license plates with their mottos. New York plates have ‘Empire State’ on them, California’s have ‘Golden State’ on them and New Jersey’s, ‘Garden State’. And then there is the rather incongruous ‘Taxation without Representation’ license plate from Washington DC. The motto, an adaptation of “no taxation without representation”, the American settlers’ rallying cry against being taxed without representation in the British Parliament, has come to represent DC’s battle for Statehood and the representation in the U.S. Congress that goes with it.
DC’s status goes back to the founding of the U.S., when James Madison, one of the writers of the U.S. Constitution, wrote in his ‘The Federalist No. 43’ essay that a federal district was required where the federal government would have sovereignty, without which “public authority might be insulted and its proceedings be interrupted, with impunity”. Madison’s fear came to pass, Lee Casey of the conservative think tank Heritage Foundation writes, when soldiers besieged the Congress as it met in Philadelphia some six months after his writings were published. Consequently, the U.S. Constitution made room for a federal district with the words, “The Congress shall have Power To… exercise exclusive Legislation in all Cases whatsoever, over such District.” The District was established with land from Maryland and Virginia in 1790. Today, the some 7,00,000 people living in Washington DC are subject to taxes, yet DC’s one delegate to the U.S. House of Representatives has no voting power. “We must protect the rights of everyone across the country, including the hundreds of thousands of American citizens who live in our nation’s capital… I plan to schedule a hearing and markup [of H.R. 51] this year,” Chairman of the House Committee on Oversight and Reform Elijah Cummings reportedly said. The Bill, even if it passes the House (a Democrat-controlled House in 1993 defeated a similar Bill), is unlikely to get past the Republican-controlled Senate because if DC achieves Statehood, it would most likely mean two more Senate seats for Democrats. In the meantime, Ms. Holmes Norton has said that she will pursue greater powers for DC via a parallel track — expanding Home Rule by introducing Bills as part of a “Free and Equal DC” series. These Bills are, for reasons mentioned above, unlikely to get very far, and DC is unlikely to get Statehood anytime soon.
